Sam’s Club shoppers praise cuts from top sirloin to chuck roast for flavor and value, though prices vary by location and pack size.

What earns a place in the Sam’s Club meat case
Beef prices have made steak feel like a splurge, which puts warehouse clubs’ per-pound prices under sharper scrutiny. Sam’s Club’s case is that you can still find cuts with strong shopper ratings and meaningful savings, from everyday sirloin to steaks suited to a special dinner. That’s a useful claim, though the value depends on the cut, your local price, and whether you’ll use a bulk purchase. This list draws on Sam’s Club customer reviews and ratings, then compares listed prices with other grocery stores and steakhouses, including Costco. Costco may have the stronger meat department, as [one comparison argues](https://www.tastingtable.com/2057834/sams-club-vs-costco-best-meat-department/), but Sam’s Club often competes on price while maintaining quality. The comparison is a reminder that “best” depends on what you’re buying. The selections range from lean, budget-friendly sirloin to more indulgent cuts. Members can also reduce the bill with offers such as [Sam’s Cash and Instant Savings](https://www.tastingtable.com/2052019/save-money-steak-sams-club/). Prices below reflect the publication date and can vary by region.Member’s Mark top sirloin: everyday value
Top sirloin is leaner than heavily marbled cuts, which helps keep it affordable. Sam’s Club’s Member’s Mark USDA Choice Angus top sirloin has a 4.4-star rating from more than 1,700 shoppers. Reviews praise its tenderness and flavor as well as its price. The cut is [among the more economical steak options](https://www.tastingtable.com/1701843/affordable-steak-cut-top-sirloin-how-to-break-down/), and Sam’s says Member’s Mark steaks are cut fresh daily in its stores. The listed online price is about $9.97 per pound—less than single Choice-grade sirloin steaks at Target, Wegmans, and Walmart, which owns Sam’s Club. One customer described the steaks as “trimmed perfectly” and comparable in flavor and tenderness to those at fine restaurants. Others call them a dependable choice for a family steak night and praise their “delicious sirloin flavor.” A shopper summed up the appeal: “At Sam’s less expensive doesn’t mean lower quality.” A cast iron skillet or grill both suit these steaks; you can also cut them into kabob pieces. For a large pack, that flexibility matters.Boneless chuck roast: a slower, versatile bargain
Chuck roast calls for time rather than a quick sear. Slow cooking brings out its tender texture and rich beef flavor, and Sam’s Club shoppers give the Member’s Mark USDA Choice Angus boneless roast 4.7 stars. At about $7.47 per pound online, it costs more than a dollar less per pound than a comparable Choice-grade boneless roast at Costco and also undercuts Target. Reviews point to marbling, tenderness, and generous size as reasons to buy. One customer called it “one of the most delicious, tender, and moist roasts I’ve ever had.” Another said the listed price seemed so low they checked with the meat department to confirm it. A reviewer reported that two roasts could feed 11 people, with leftovers for sandwiches and hash. Pot roast is the obvious use, but the cut can stretch into fajitas, beef stroganoff, or [slow cooker birria tacos](https://www.tastingtable.com/1319250/slow-cooker-birria-recipe/). If you’re looking for a flexible cut for several meals, this roast makes a stronger value argument than its steakhouse-ready counterparts. There are plenty of [pot roast recipes](https://www.tastingtable.com/2060576/pot-roast-recipes-to-try/) to put it to work.T-bone: a restaurant-style cut at a lower price
At $15.97 per pound, Member’s Mark USDA Choice Angus T-bone is one of Sam’s Club’s pricier steaks. Still, T-bones generally cost less than ribeyes, and Sam’s price is below what shoppers would pay at many retailers. A single T-bone at Texas Roadhouse, Saltgrass Steak House, or LongHorn Steakhouse can cost more than $30. Members describe Sam’s T-bones as tender, well-marbled, and worth the price. One reviewer wrote, “T-Bone steaks from Sam’s are always awesome,” adding that the meat quality is excellent. The cut’s thickness helps it stay juicy on the grill, a popular cooking method among shoppers. Grilling also gives you more control over heat, useful because a T-bone combines strip and tenderloin sections that can cook at different rates. A few [simple temperature and timing tips](https://www.tastingtable.com/1281788/simple-trick-never-overcook-t-bone-steak/) can help keep either side from overcooking. The opening image shows fresh cowboy ribeyes displayed at Sam’s Club. The next selection is the Member’s Mark USDA Choice Angus beef bone-in cowboy ribeye, pictured here:
The visible fragment ends before giving the cowboy ribeye’s price, rating, or review details.A big steakhouse cut at a warehouse price
Member’s Mark’s USDA Choice Angus cowboy ribeye makes the case for buying steak at Sam’s Club: it’s a large, bone-in cut with the rich look and flavor people expect from a steakhouse, priced online at about $14.47 per pound. The [difference between a cowboy steak and a regular ribeye](https://www.tastingtable.com/1299187/what-cowboy-cut-steak-what-sets-apart-from-regular-ribeye/) is largely its prominent bone and larger size. Online retailers can ask $60 to $75 for a single steak, so Sam’s Club’s price stands out. Customer reviews suggest the lower price hasn’t meant a disappointing steak. One shopper called it one of the best ribeyes they’d bought, praising its marbling and generous size; another described reverse-searing it in a smoker, then crisping the fatty edges. Reverse searing is a forgiving way to cook a premium cut because the gentler heat helps prevent overcooking. If you want a stronger smoky flavor, [marinating and grilling a cowboy cut](https://www.tastingtable.com/1686109/absolute-best-way-cook-serve-cowboy-cut-steak/) is another option: the marbling helps keep the meat juicy. There are also [good reasons to reverse-sear steak](https://www.tastingtable.com/1186339/delicious-benefits-to-reverse-searing-steak/).For a familiar ribeye, skip the restaurant markup
The boneless Member’s Mark USDA Choice Angus ribeye is the more straightforward pick. Each pack contains three steaks and costs about $14.97 per pound online. Costco’s Choice ribeye costs more than $2 extra per pound, while Outback Steakhouse and LongHorn charge roughly $30 for one ribeye. Cooking at home looks like a good deal by comparison, especially if you’re feeding a few people. The product has a 4.6-star rating from about 7,000 Sam’s Club customer ratings. Reviewers praise the marbling and say the steaks can deliver restaurant-level tenderness and flavor, though some acknowledge they aren’t the cheapest option. Their point is that the price still feels justified. These thick cuts work on the grill or in a pan with a butter baste; follow a few [ribeye cooking tips](https://www.tastingtable.com/2235468/ribeye-steak-cooking-tips/) and the extra effort can pay off. That’s the useful distinction between these two Sam’s Club steaks: the cowboy ribeye is a showpiece, while the boneless pack is a practical way to serve classic ribeye at home. Neither is a bargain in the sense of being the cheapest beef available. The appeal is getting a premium style of steak for less than a restaurant meal or a comparable online single cut.
Discussion
Sign in to join the discussion.