Top Chef winner and former McDonald’s chef Tristen Epps-Long recommends adding extra butter to a McMuffin, with sauces and cheese as other options.

A small butter adjustment can change the whole sandwich
A little extra butter may be the simplest way to improve a McDonald’s McMuffin. Tristen Epps-Long, winner of Top Chef season 22 and a former McDonald’s chef, told Tasting Table to spread “plenty of butter on the muffin itself.” His advice focuses on the bread, rather than asking a customer to rebuild the sandwich around a new topping or a more elaborate combination. The reason is practical: an English muffin’s nooks and crannies give softened butter places to settle, so it can flavor more than just the surface.
McDonald’s English muffins already come buttered, but that doesn’t necessarily mean the butter will be prominent by the time you eat the sandwich. Heat melts it quickly, and the muffin’s other ingredients compete for attention. Adding more just before eating can give the bread a richer, creamier texture and make the egg and breakfast meat seem less dry, particularly if they’ve spent extra time on the griddle. It’s a modest adjustment, but one aimed at a specific weakness: a sandwich that tastes dry or whose bread gets lost behind its filling.
There’s a useful distinction here between adding richness and adding moisture. Butter won’t change the sandwich’s construction, and it won’t undo every effect of extended cooking. It can, though, soften the impression of dry bread and make the different parts feel more connected. A little more fat, in the right place.
Customers can ask for extra butter when ordering in the McDonald’s app, or pick up a packet or two of whipped butter and spread it themselves. The second route gives you more control over how much goes on and where it lands. That matters because the muffin is the target: spreading the butter across its surface lets the bread carry the flavor through each bite. A packet is also a low-commitment way to find out whether the adjustment works for your sandwich.
Sauces and other ways to upgrade a McMuffin
For added moisture, mayonnaise is a straightforward option. It brings a creamy layer that can change the feel of a bite without requiring a different sandwich. McDonald’s Creamy Ranch Sauce offers a herbal tang, while Big Mac sauce can add creamy, sweet, savory and pickle flavors if a restaurant can provide it in the morning. That availability caveat matters: a sauce listed as an option elsewhere on the menu may not be available for every breakfast order.
Here's the thing: a sauce does more than make a sandwich wetter. Its flavor can take over, especially in a compact breakfast sandwich where each ingredient has limited room to stand out. Ranch shifts the flavor toward herbs; Big Mac sauce adds several notes at once. If you're working out which addition suits a McMuffin, think about whether you want the egg and breakfast meat to remain central or want the sauce to become a bigger part of the bite. More flavor isn't automatically a better balance.
There are spicier choices, too. Creamy Chili McCrispy Strip Dip, made for chicken strips, pairs a little heat with sweetness; Spicy Pepper Sauce is available to order through the app. Both can change the sandwich’s character more sharply than butter, which mainly amplifies richness in the muffin. The names and intended uses give a reader some clues, but the source doesn’t establish how every restaurant serves them with breakfast. Availability is part of the choice, not a detail to assume away.
A hash brown changes texture as well as flavor. Slide one into the sandwich and its crisp exterior can contrast with the muffin and filling, while its soft interior adds another substantial layer. That can balance a dry McMuffin, provided the hash brown hasn’t been fried too long. The trade-off is straightforward: the sandwich gets more filling and crunch, but the added layer can also make its existing ingredients less prominent. A second slice of cheese is a quieter change. It adds more melt to each bite, with less of the crisp contrast a hash brown brings.
These options solve different problems. Butter targets the bread; mayonnaise and sauces add moisture and flavor; a hash brown supplies texture and bulk; extra cheese increases the melted richness. They’re best treated as separate adjustments at first, so you can tell what each one contributes. (And this is the part most people overlook.) A sandwich can become heavier without becoming better balanced.
What these small changes can tell you
Butter is the easiest place to start because it works with the McMuffin’s existing structure. The muffin already has the nooks and crannies Epps-Long points to, and the sandwich already includes ingredients that can taste dry after extra time on the griddle. Adding butter addresses both the bread’s flavor and the overall impression of dryness without introducing a new, strong flavor. This is more significant than it looks: a small change to the base can affect how the whole sandwich reads.
That said, the best adjustment depends on what you find lacking. If the muffin seems dry, butter or mayonnaise may be the more direct fix. If you want sharper flavor, one of the sauces could make more sense. If texture is the problem, the hash brown adds contrast. And if you mainly want a richer bite, extra cheese is an option. None of these changes can guarantee a better result in every order; preparation and personal taste still shape the experience.
For readers who don’t want to guess, changing one thing at a time is a sensible way to compare. Start with the butter, since it’s the suggestion tied directly to the muffin itself, then decide whether the sandwich needs more moisture, more flavor, or more texture. A single-sentence verdict: keep it simple.
The broader point is modest but useful. Fast-food customizations work best when they answer a specific complaint about the food in front of you, rather than accumulating toppings for their own sake. What this means for you is that an extra packet of butter may be enough; a sauce, a hash brown or more cheese can wait until you know what the sandwich is missing. McMuffin upgrades aren’t a puzzle with one correct combination. They’re small choices about where you want richness, crunch and flavor to show up.
Discussion
Sign in to join the discussion.