From easy-to-make pizza to no-frosting cake, these discontinued boxed foods offered practical shortcuts that still appeal to home cooks.

Six boxed foods that earned another look
The best case for bringing back an old grocery product isn’t nostalgia by itself. It’s the clever shortcut it offered: homemade pizza without measuring every ingredient, or a cake that needed no frosting and almost no cleanup. Some of these ideas still fit modern kitchens better than the products that replaced them. Boxed foods have always been a mix of lasting staples and brief experiments. Kraft mac and cheese remains a familiar fixture, while plenty of once popular cake mixes and dinner kits have faded away. The six products in this list were discontinued, but each had a practical appeal that’s easy to understand today.Appian Way Pizza
[Image: Box of Appian Way Pizza](https://www.tastingtable.com/img/gallery/6-old-school-boxed-foods-that-deserve-a-second-chance/appian-way-pizza-1792702797.webp) *Image credit: [Kawfene1 / Reddit](https://www.reddit.com/r/70s/comments/1evhp7v/appian_way_pizza/)* Appian Way Pizza made a fresh baked pie feel within reach at a time when pizza was spreading across the country. Frank Fiorillo, of Worcester, Massachusetts, introduced the mix in 1948 under the name Roman Pizza Mix. It was later renamed Appian Way, and became, by most accounts, the first commercial boxed pizza mix. It remained on shelves for more than 60 years. The box included flour mix, dry yeast, tomato sauce, and cheese. Add water to make the dough, assemble the pizza, then bake. That’s a tidy solution for anyone who wanted a homemade pie without tracking down and measuring each component, and shoppers took to it. The product was phased out around 2019 as demand declined and competition grew. Its fans haven’t all moved on: former customers still share family memories online, and some single out the sauce. A [Facebook group](https://www.facebook.com/groups/bringbackappianwaypizza/) is devoted to bringing it back. Today, most supermarket pizza is sold frozen and ready to bake, though boxed kits persist. [Chef Boyardee pizza kits](https://www.tastingtable.com/2177254/55-cent-pizza-kit-childhood-favorite-still-exists/) have been around for more than seven decades.Betty Crocker Snackin’ Cake
[Image: Betty Crocker Snackin’ Cake packaging](https://www.tastingtable.com/img/gallery/6-old-school-boxed-foods-that-deserve-a-second-chance/betty-crocker-snackin-cake-1792703247.webp) *Image credit: [Elbow Room Innovations / eBay](https://r.bttn.io?btn_ref=org-225e4e0aac880b8f&btn_url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.ebay.com%2Fitm%2F276288865609%3F_skw%3Dbetty%2Bcrocker%2Bsnackin%2Bcake%26itmmeta%3D01M5HPPGN9ZR2V54QVB2TSXDB9%26hash%3Ditem4054198549%3Ag%3AK5oAAOSwtC1lpxvS%26itmprp%3Denc%253AAQALAAABACHNgUiiE%252FjQhlDTaMiAde%252BvYDYduLubfK3lEZQf1c246VqAOues54SGdB6zrXKbxA4eqFM%252BT5ZwJ6zZWsTLRY0w7gC1ExlLvrjC1fdFRt%252Fc0bwgD1GbFcUXsQHvsPtv3IlMF8dXp4rRG9tpNTCfgkcEbBs9zEDMRwja8GgKk1w7aOHEdXrpiF%252FlfeGKhHJWVaDyRzLZTb1RSW9PhO8%252FJxHsptIqMh68mbQLTsffN6BYy8waz8pY1cRZl3kafgtsiykc372WB0OQdNGYhEeN2fyuXP%252BsOgPekwcjWHT2zaXUeRtqzgpTP1Pr3z1X54OEJEmVNiFsv2BHS81RWRTqv7k%253D%257Ctkp%253ABk9SR4KL2rasaA&btn_pub_ref=2294873-in_text-3)* Betty Crocker’s Snackin’ Cake mixes arrived in the 1970s with a straightforward promise: a moist, flavorful sheet cake without frosting, layers, or much fuss. You could mix the ingredients right in the baking pan, adding water and vinegar to the dry mix. It’s hard to argue with the convenience. There were eight flavors, including Banana Walnut, Coconut Pecan, Chocolate Almond, and Applesauce Raisin. The mixes were discontinued in 2012, but fans still remember them fondly. One commenter in a [Reddit discussion](https://www.reddit.com/r/vintageads/comments/1g2i8kh/betty_crocker_snackin_cakes_1970s/) called them “the bomb!!!”; others asked for their return. Snackin’ Cake belongs in the boxed baking hall of fame, alongside other [discontinued Betty Crocker mixes that deserve a revival](https://www.tastingtable.com/2285045/discontinued-betty-crocker-cake-mixes-deserve-comeback/).Pillsbury Pink Lemonade Angel Food Cake Mix
[Image: Advertisement for Pillsbury Pink Lemonade Angel Food Cake Mix](https://www.tastingtable.com/img/gallery/6-old-school-boxed-foods-that-deserve-a-second-chance/pillsbury-pink-lemonade-angel-food-cake-mix-1792702799.webp) *Image credit: [Pillsbury / Reddit](https://www.reddit.com/media?url=https%3A%2F%2Fpreview.redd.it%2Fpink-lemonade-cake-recipe-link-v0-5hemdwyr43ta1.png%3Fwidth%3D1201%26format%3Dpng%26auto%3Dwebp%26s%3Dc123c3d3b189763f006ef64a21bf4ee1731dfbb5)* Pillsbury’s [Pink Lemonade Angel Food Cake Mix](https://www.tastingtable.com/2019381/discontinued-pillsbury-boxed-cake-mix-pink-lemonade/) made a familiar light cake more playful: pastel pink, citrusy, and paired with a matching Fluffy Pink Lemonade Frosting Mix. Both appeared in 1961. The cake was advertised as “cool and tart,” and its airy height came from 14.4 egg whites in the mix. Frosted, it could pass as a centerpiece dessert without revealing its boxed origins. No one seems to know exactly when or why it disappeared. There’s no obvious modern equivalent on store shelves, either. If you want to recreate the look and flavor, add lemon extract or fresh zest and a few drops of pink food coloring to a classic [angel food cake recipe](https://www.tastingtable.com/1131276/light-and-fluffy-angel-food-cake-recipe/). It’s a plausible route to a suitably retro summer dessert, though it won’t be quite the same mix.Pillsbury Orange Cake Mix
[Image: Advertisement for Pillsbury Orange Cake Mix](https://www.tastingtable.com/img/gallery/6-old-school-boxed-foods-that-deserve-a-second-chance/pillsbury-orange-cake-mix-1792702800.webp) *Image credit: [Breannagrace / eBay](https://r.bttn.io?btn_ref=org-225e4e0aac880b8f&btn_url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.ebay.com%2Fitm%2F358220737843&btn_pub_ref=2294873-in_text-5)* Orange cake has a smaller footprint in today’s baking aisle than chocolate, vanilla, or lemon. That wasn’t always the case. Pillsbury’s Orange Cake Mix was a popular choice in the 1950s, prized for its moist texture and bright citrus flavor. Advertisements attributed that flavor to special crystals made from real oranges. The pitch was simple: a sweet, zesty cake without needing an actual orange in the kitchen. Pillsbury later discontinued the mix, but the idea still sounds appealing. [We’d welcome its return](https://www.tastingtable.com/2031868/discontinued-pillsbury-food-bring-back-orange-cake-mix/). For a current substitute, Duncan Hines Orange Supreme Cake Mix has drawn positive reviews from Walmart customers.Schilling’s Dinner Mexicana kits show how convenience food can still leave room for a cook’s own touch. In the 1970s, the brand offered a quick route to Mexican-inspired family dinners, alongside better-known names such as Old El Paso and Ortega. The kits handled the seasoning; home cooks supplied the ground beef and finished the meal with fresh toppings.
The range included Tamale Pie, Tostados, and Taco Casserole. Jalapeños, guacamole, sour cream, or extra cheese could make each dish feel more personal. That balance—an easy starting point with room to customize—is likely part of why the kits still have fans. In a Reddit discussion, one former customer wished the Tamale Pie kit were still available, saying it brought back “so many pleasant memories.” Another recalled craving the Taco Casserole, especially its Frito-like chip topping. Some commenters even posted copycat recipes.
Duncan Hines Dutch Topping cake mixes
Duncan Hines still sells a broad range of boxed cake mix flavors, but its early-1960s Dutch Topping line had a particularly appealing idea: pair a simple sponge with a crumb topping, and get a cake that looked more involved than it was.
Home bakers could choose Apple ’N Spice, Butterscotch Crunch, or Cinnamon Raisin. Apple ’N Spice included canned apple slices and cinnamon sugar; Butterscotch Crunch added almonds; Cinnamon Raisin used a spiced sugar crumb over fruit-studded cake. The batter took less than a minute to mix by hand, then the topping went on before baking. The ads suggested serving the cakes warm. A scoop of vanilla ice cream sounds like a fitting finish.
These old mixes are a reminder that convenience products can earn affection when they deliver a little character along with the shortcut. That’s a harder trick than simply making dinner or dessert faster.
Discussion
Sign in to join the discussion.